Understanding Wives of Alcoholics: The Faces of Suffering Susan, Controlling Catherine, Wavering Winifred, and Punitive Polly

Home » Blog » Understanding Wives of Alcoholics: The Faces of Suffering Susan, Controlling Catherine, Wavering Winifred, and Punitive Polly

Alcoholism, or alcohol use disorder (AUD), is a pervasive disease that affects not only the individual but also their relationships and family dynamics. Husbands’ alcoholism often creates challenging environments at home, impacting physical health, mental disorders, and self-esteem. Those struggling with AUD can benefit from understanding the various ways alcoholism manifests.

In the 1930s, social workers observed that wives of alcoholics exhibited symptoms like anxiety and depression, as reported by Lewis (1937). This led to theories exploring alcohol-related family symptoms, suggesting these were not just reactions to living with an alcoholic, but part of a broader phenomenon.

The disturbed personality hypothesis proposed that wives of alcoholic men were themselves disturbed, resolving neurotic conflicts through marriage (McCrady and Epstein, 1996). Whalen (1953) expanded this, suggesting repressed aggression and dependence underlie their symptoms. He created profiles to illustrate these conflicts: “Punitive Polly” for aggression, “Controlling Catherine” for control, “Suffering Susan” for masochistic tendencies, and “Wavering Winifred” for ambivalence.

This article discusses four different archetypes: Suffering Susan, Controlling Catherine, Wavering Winifred, and Punitive Polly. Understanding these archetypes can help families support their loved ones and guide them toward recovery and appropriate treatment options.

Note: Not every wife of an alcoholic fits neatly into one of the four categories discussed in this article. These archetypes stem from research conducted by Lewis in the 1930s, which sought to explore the effects of alcoholism on family dynamics. This article is intended to review and reflect on that historical hypothesis, not to define or categorize individuals. For a more accurate and contemporary understanding of the psychological effects experienced by spouses of alcoholics, it is important to refer to modern diagnostic criteria, such as those found in the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders). A thorough DSM-5 assessment can provide a clearer and more individualized picture of mental health impacts.

Suffering Susan

Characteristics

Suffering Susan is used to describe a woman suffering from AUD who appears withdrawn and depressed. Her alcohol addiction can result in feelings of intense sadness, and her depression causes her to distance herself emotionally from both friends and family, making it challenging for those close to her to offer support.

Her alcohol addiction, often influenced by excessive alcohol consumption and a family history of substance abuse, results in feelings of intense sadness, guilt, and shame.. She blames herself for her AUD, believing she has failed herself and her family.

Denial is another characteristic of Suffering Susan. She may deny the severity of her alcoholism, thus shielding herself from the reality of her situation. This ultimately prevents her from seeking treatment.

Impact on Family

While Suffering Susan may not realize her family is affected, the impact on her family is typically profound.

Firstly, her alcoholism creates a somber and stressful home environment. Her depression casts a shadow over everything, making the home feel heavy with sadness. The atmosphere will affect everyone in the household. Children may sense something is wrong without fully understanding what the issues are. And whereas home should be a place of comfort, it is now a place of anxiety.

Family members may also feel helpless and frustrated as Suffering Susan continues to withdraw and distance herself. They may wish to offer compassion and help without knowing how to.

Support Strategies

Finding ways to support Suffering Susan can be difficult. However, some strategies may be effective.

• Encourage Open Communication and Emotional Support: By encouraging open communication, Suffering Susan will feel heard and understood without judgment. It will also help her feel less isolated and depressed.
• Suggest Counseling or Support Groups: Support groups and counseling can help Suffering Susan get out into the world and meet people with similar experiences. Support groups can also provide emotional support and advice.
• Provide a Non-Judgmental Space for Susan to Express Her Feelings: Encourage Suffering Susan to talk about the reasons for her addiction without blaming or criticizing her. Listening actively and offering reassurance can let her know her struggle with alcoholism is okay. This approach may encourage her to seek treatment.

Controlling Catherine

Characteristics

Controlling Catherine is another archetype who is characterized by her manipulative and domineering behavior. She often resorts to domineering tactics to maintain a sense of control in the home. She may use intimidation or emotional blackmail, for example. This need to dominate could stem from a need to hide her vulnerability.

Controlling Catherine will also try to control family dynamics to hide her alcoholism. She may do this by micromanaging the household, dictating everyone’s daily routines, and watching everyone’s activities to try and hide her own secrets.

In addition, Controlling Catherine uses alcohol to cope with stress. Drinking gives her a false sense of empowerment and exacerbates her dominating character.

Impact on Family

Controlling Catherine’s desire to control every aspect of her family’s activities creates a tense and rigid household. Her domineering behavior means family members must follow her rules and expectations, leaving little room for relaxation and pleasure.

Family members may also feel suffocated and powerless as her constant monitoring prevents them from making their own decisions or expressing how they feel. Children may find it difficult to develop a sense of independence due to the amount of micromanaging taking place in the home.

Support Strategies

Finding support strategies for Controlling Catherine is difficult as she is reluctant to relinquish control. However, here are some helpful tactics.

• Set Clear Boundaries and Maintain Consistency: By setting clear boundaries, family members can establish healthy interactions at home. Spouses can also let Controlling Catherine know there will be consequences if these boundaries are crossed. Consistently adhering to these boundaries is key as it prevents confusion and establishes a healthy routine.
• Encourage Catherine to Seek Professional Help: Encourage Controlling Catherine to seek professional help so she can examine her issues: her addiction to alcohol and her need for control. Emphasize that seeking treatment means taking control of her addictive behavior.
• Promote Healthy Coping Mechanisms and Stress Management Techniques: Encourage Controlling Catherine to find healthier ways to cope with stress. Help her discover activities that could improve her mental health and relieve stress, such as exercise or yoga.

Wavering Winifred

Characteristics

The Wavering Winifred archetype wavers in her journey with alcoholism. She has cycles of progress alongside cycles of setbacks. There may be days and weeks when she seems to be in control over her drinking, and then months when she returns to her old habits of heavy drinking.

Wavering Winifred finds it challenging to commit to her recovery. It may be a fear of living without alcohol or it may be a lack of confidence. This often manifests as inconsistent behavior: not fully participating in treatment programs and giving up when programs become too difficult.

Wavering Winifred also feels conflicted and uncertain about her alcoholism. She may be aware that she has a drinking problem, but she may not want to accept the fact that change is necessary. This inner conflict makes it hard for her to commit fully to treatment.

Impact on Family

While Wavering Winifred does have cycles of progress, this back-and-forth behavior creates an unpredictable and unstable home environment, unfortunately. Family members may not know what to expect from day to day as the days or weeks of normal behavior are interrupted by weeks or months of heavy drinking. This inconsistency can make it difficult for family members to establish routines and feelings of security.

Family members may also experience mixed emotions and confusion. They may feel hopeful during her periods of sobriety, and feel a crashing sense of disappointment when she relapses. This unpredictable behavior can lead to feelings of resentment.

Support Strategies

There are various ways to support the Wavering Winifred archetype:

• Reinforce the Importance of Ongoing Treatment and Support: Although Wavering Winifred may be indecisive about treatment, continue to reinforce why treatment is important. Attend meetings with her to help her stay committed.
• Celebrate Small Victories and Progress: Celebrating small victories and progress can boost Wavering Winifred’s morale. Celebrate milestones or any positive steps she takes towards her recovery. Recognizing small victories can encourage her to continue with her treatment.
• Provide a Stable and Supportive Environment: Provide a stable and supportive environment at home, so she doesn’t feel judged or criticized. Encourage her to talk about her wavering commitment and her struggles. This may motivate her to find her own solutions.

Punitive Polly

Characteristics

Punitive Polly is an alcoholic archetype who exhibits aggressive and punitive behavior towards family members. Her anger towards others manifests as hostility, and she frequently belittles, criticizes, or punishes family members.

Punitive Polly also uses alcohol as an outlet for her anger and frustration. Her drinking fuels her aggression, causing an uptick in harmful behavior.

She also blames others for her problems and her alcoholism, claiming work and family responsibilities push her to drink. This blame-shifting behavior prevents her from taking responsibility for her own weaknesses and places an unfair burden on others.

Impact on Family

Punitive Polly’s alcoholic behavior creates a hostile and abusive household. Her harsh and critical treatment of family members makes them feel unsafe and unloved. Family members may experience verbal or physical abuse. The constant tension in the home affects daily interactions. Children, especially, will absorb this dysfunction and think it’s normal behavior.

Family members may also live in fear and anxiety, constantly fearing Punitive Polly’s next outburst. This state of continuous stress and anxiety can affect their emotional well-being.

Support Strategies

Supporting Punitive Polly is challenging, but some strategies can help.

• Ensure the Safety of All Family Members: Firstly, ensure all family members are safe. If Punitive Poly poses an immediate risk to children in the home, then they must be protected. Family members must have a safe place to go when violence erupts in the home. Open communication can help keep everyone safe as well.
• Seek Professional Intervention and Possibly Legal Assistance: Professional intervention may be necessary, especially if Punitive Polly is violent and aggressive. Talk with mental health professionals and addiction specialists. They can help provide guidance. In extreme cases, legal assistance may be necessary, such as restraining orders.
• Encourage Polly to Attend Anger Management and Addiction Treatment Programs: Encouraging Punitive Polly to participate in anger management and addiction treatment programs is crucial. These programs can help her manage her anger and reduce her aggressive tendencies.

Common Challenges Across Archetypes

Denial and Stigma

One of the common challenges across all the above archetypes is denial and stigma. For many people suffering from alcoholism, the fear of being stigmatized by their family and friends can prevent them from getting treatment. To help combat this, try to create safe spaces where those suffering can talk about their disorder without being judged. Encourage them to join support groups, such as Alcoholics Anonymous (AA).

Personal denial is another significant challenge. Denial involves refusing to accept that you have a drinking problem or that your problem is severe. One of the best ways to overcome denial is to seek professional counseling. Therapists and counselors often provide an objective evaluation of the situation. Once an outside counselor has identified and labeled the problem, the alcoholic can then admit to having a problem and seek treatment.

Family Dynamics

Each archetype affects their family dynamics differently. In all cases, however, family members are negatively impacted. Children may feel confused, neglected, or belittled while spouses may experience high levels of anxiety and stress. To heal and rebuild relationships at home, family therapy is essential.

Family therapy can help improve communication within a structured environment. Therapy can also address the damage caused by alcoholism over the years. It provides a safe space where family members can express their feelings and work through conflicts.

Access to Treatment

Finding treatment for each archetype poses a significant challenge as there may be financial constraints as well. Treatment for addiction, such as rehab programs, can be expensive; and many families may simply not have the financial resources.

In some cases, family members living in remote areas may have limited access to rehab services. This can prevent them from getting the treatment they need.

If an inpatient rehab program is financially out of reach, find a free support group, such as Alcoholics Anonymous. Families can look into free counseling services and free rehab programs as well. Some centers provide financial assistance or sliding scale fees.

Furthermore, family members can call hotlines and look for online resources that can connect individuals to local services. Community and health services can provide resources, too.

Live Free Recovery Services

Recognizing and understanding the different archetypes of alcoholism is crucial to effectively helping them. Each archetype will impact family members differently, and each will have unique challenges when it comes to finding treatment. For wives of alcoholics, these challenges can be particularly profound as they navigate the complexities of an alcoholic family and the associated health issues.

Empathy, support, and professional help are essential in guiding each archetype toward recovery. By approaching each situation with understanding and empathy, family members can help create a supportive and healthier environment. Social workers play a crucial role in providing this support, addressing enabling behaviors, and promoting healthy drinking patterns.

In America, the prevalence of alcohol abuse and the associated withdrawal symptoms highlight the need for effective treatment options. Programs like Al-Anon offer valuable support for those dealing with codependent relationships and the etiology of addiction. Advocacy and understanding of these issues are vital in the recovery process.

If you or someone you love is suffering from an alcohol use disorder, contact Live Free Recovery Services in New Hamshire. We offer various programs, such as inpatient treatment, intensive outpatient, and long-term rehab, for those suffering from substance use disorders. We also provide support for those seeking help with the guidance of experienced professionals.

When you’re ready to start on your journey to sobriety, reach out to our team. Our services are designed to address the complex needs of individuals and families, ensuring a comprehensive approach to recovery. Whether you are in your recovery journey or just beginning, we are here to support you.